Table 2: Study results sorted by biomarker.
Sample type | Study design | Biomarkers | Bias rating (biomarker & measurement) | Stress construct & measure | Bias rating (stress construct & measurement) | Results | Reference |
HPA axis | |||||||
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; ACTH; plasma |
Strong | Occupational stress; ERI & OC scales | Strong | High OC relates to lower ACTH & salivary cortisol; HPA axis hyporeactivity in teachers high in OC | [39] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Strong | ERI; vital exhaustion; burnout; ERI & OC scales | Strong | No associations between cortisol & burnout, exhaustion, or ERI | [40] |
Childcare workers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Physical workload; experience and evaluation of work questionnaire (VBBA) | Fair | Higher cortisol, particularly at beginning of day, related to lower-quality caregiving behavior above & beyond other predictors | [41] |
Nursery & primary school teachers | Experimental | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Burnout; Spanish burnout inventory | Fair | CBT intervention reduced psychosomatic complaints & sig. increased cortisol levels pre- & post-intervention | [42] |
School teachers | Experimental | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Burnout; psychological distress; symptom checklist 90-R; MBI-ES | Strong | Mindfulness intervention reduced psychological symptoms & burnout, & increased cortisol. Control condition had decreases in cortisol functioning overtime & increases in burnout | [43] |
Childcare workers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Perceived stress; TICS | Fair | Perceived stress predicted quality of care; cortisol did not differ between home- & center-based care | [44] |
Early career teachers | Experimental | Salivary cortisol; CAR | Strong | Perceived stress; burnout; MBI | Strong | Intervention showed decrease in perceived stress but not decrease in burnout; CAR & average resting cortisol decreased from baseline to week 6; pre- & post-session salivary cortisol levels show immediate decrease in cortisol for weeks 4 to 6 | [45] |
Middle school teachers | Longitudinal | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Perceived stress; burnout; MBI, PSS | Fair | Depersonalization & ambition were associated with less steep CAR. In contrast, ambition & perceived stress were associated with less steep sAA awakening response | [46] |
Middle school teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Burnout; perceived stress | Fair | CAR was blunted in the spring compared to the fall; effective emotion regulation buffered this effect | [14] |
Secondary school teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; immune assay | Fair | Job strain | Fair | No association between job strain & salivary cortisol/sAA. Older teachers & special needs teachers exhibited higher stress levels with lower log salivary IgA levels | [47] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Burnout; occupational stress | Good | No sig. associations between salivary cortisol or CAR with burnout or job satisfaction | [48] |
Early childcare workers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Strong | Work demands & resources | Fair | Minor associations between cortisol activity & job resources & dem&s. Cortisol activity related to pedagogical work & teamwork; higher quality teamwork, the lower morning cortisol values | [49] |
Early childcare workers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; sAA | Strong | Burnout; work engagement; MBI | Strong | No associations among stress biomarkers, work engagement & burnout. No relation between cortisol & either burnout or job satisfaction. Teachers with high burnout showed lower job satisfaction but no cortisol differences | [50] |
Nursery schoolteachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | ERI | Strong | No association between ERI or OC & biomarkers | [51] |
Nursery schoolteachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; DHEA | Strong | Job strain; job content questionnaire | Fair | Negative association between DHEA & social support | [52] |
Kindergarten teachers | Cross-sectional | Hair cortisol | Strong | ERI; occupational stress | Strong | Positive relationship between ERI & hair cortisol | [53] |
Kindergarten teachers | Cross-sectional | Hair cortisol | Strong | NFR; job demands | Strong | NFR related to higher hair cortisol; seen as precursor to chronic fatigue | [54] |
Kindergarten teachers | Cross-sectional | Hair cortisol | Strong | Emotional labor | Fair | Emotional labor related to increased HPA axis activity in hair cortisol; NFR negatively related to hair cortisol | [55] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Strong | Burnout; perceived stress; MBI, PSS, TBS | Strong | High levels of burnout associated with blunted cortisol. Differential effects of chronic stress & burnout on HPA axis |
[56] |
School teachers | Experimental | Salivary cortisol; BP; HR | Strong | burnout; MBI, TSI | Strong | Mindfulness intervention decreased depression, burnout, anxiety, & occupational stress. No sig. physiological changes 3 months later | [57] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; HR | Strong | Burnout; teacher self-efficacy; MBI, TSES, PANAS | Strong | Self-efficacy protective for biomarkers; improved HRV & attenuated morning cortisol | [58] |
Preschool teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Subjective stress; fatigue; job demands | Fair | High stress teachers had higher CAR; high stress teachers engaged in more pedagogical preparation than low stress teachers, suggesting preparation & social support may be protective | [59] |
School teachers | Longitudinal | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Job strain | Fair | Burnout associated with blunted cortisol response; Job strain/work stress associated with elevated cortisol levels | [60] |
School teachers | Longitudinal | Blood sample | Good | Occupational stress; stress coping styles (adapted measures for teachers) | Fair | Sig. changes in blood chemistry, including cortisol & alcohol indicators over time; changes in physiological responses related to increases in stress. Blunted cortisol response at time 2 one year later | [61] |
Elementary school teachers | Experimental | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Occupational stress; perceived stress; anxiety; depression; OSI, ASS | Strong | Stress management intervention showed short-term reductions in depression, anxiety & stress. Both groups showed reduction in salivary cortisol at post-test | [62] |
Kindergarten teachers | Person-centered cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol | Fair | Occupational stress | Fair | Poorly-trained end-career teachers had blunted cortisol & flatter slopes compared to other teachers. Education & experience variation (combined with similar levels of well-being at work, own poverty risk, & class size) set teachers apart from each other | [32] |
Primary school teachers | Cross-sectional | Salivary cortisol; sAA; HRV | Strong | Perceived stress; TICS | Strong | Higher cortisol & perceived stress on workdays compared to free days; lower HRV on workdays compared to free days | [63] |
Cardiovascular system | |||||||
School teachers | Cross-sectional | BP; urinary hormone excretion | Strong | Occupational stress; JCQ | Fair | Teachers had lower BP & lower urinary hormone excretion than nurses; occupational stress not related to biomarkers | [64] |
Elementary school teachers | Experimental | BP; HR | Fair | Anxiety | Poor | Aromatherapy may have positive impacts on cardiovascular indicators of stress | [65] |
Primary school teachers | Cross-sectional | BP | Poor | Quality of life | Poor | A combination of chronic health conditions (obesity, hypertension) negatively impacts health among rural teachers | [66] |
Elementary school teachers | Experimental | BP; HRV | Fair | Workload; anxiety; BAI, objective number of classes taught each day | Fair | Older teachers benefit more from aromatherapy than younger teachers; BMI moderates aromatherapy impact on teacher anxiety & stress | [67] |
Preschool & primary school teachers | Cross-sectional | HRV | Fair | Work place location | Poor | Rural teachers had higher HRV than city teachers, indicating better autonomic control | [68] |
Secondary school teachers | Cross-sectional | BP | Poor | Stress cognitions; perceived stress; stress cognitions questionnaire, BFB, stress-short test | Strong | Strong relationships between BP & psychological features; Associations between lower BP & mood moderated by situational stress | [69] |
Immune system | |||||||
School teachers | Experimental | Immune assays, IL-6 | Strong | ERI; OC | Strong | Less effective anti-inflammatory regulation by IL-6 in teachers suffering from chronic work stress (ERI) | [70] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Immune assays; salivary cortisol | Strong | ERI; vital exhaustion; anxiety; depression | Strong | Increased pro-inflammatory activity in teachers high on ERI & OC | [71] |
High school teachers | Experimental | Immune assays; ATCH; blood cortisol; HR; BP | Strong | Daily hassles | Fair | No stressor effect on endocrine variables; increases in HR & BP blood pressure, with similar effect across high & low stress groups. Differences in NK & T cell responses in low & high stress groups | [72] |
Primary school teachers | Cross-sectional | Immune assays for IgA, IgG, IgM, C1-INH, C3; urine sample | Strong | Occupational stress; JSRS | Fair | In teachers, immunoglobin (IgA, IgG, & IgM) concentrations correlated with work-related problems | [73] |
School teachers | Cross-sectional | Immune assays for TNF; IL-4; IL-10 | Strong | Burnout; MBI | Strong | Higher total burnout symptoms relate to higher TNF levels & a higher TNF/IL-4 ratio. Higher levels of burnout relate to decrease IL-4 levels | [74] |
Note. ACTH = adrenocorticotropic hormone; ASS = anxiety and stress scale; BAI = beck anxiety inventory; BMI = body mass index; BP = blood pressure; CAR = cortisol awakening response; CBT = cognitive behavioral therapy; DHEA = dehydroepi & rosterone; ERI = effort reward imbalance; HPA = hypothalamic pituitary axis; HR = heart rate; HRV = heart rate variability; IgA = immunoglobulin A; IgG = immunoglobulin G; IgM = immunoglobulin M; IL = interleukin; JCQ = job content questionnaire; JSRS = job stress rating scale; MBI-ES = Maslach burnout inventory-educators survey; NFR = need for recovery; OC = overcommitment; OSI = occupational stress indicator; PANAS = positive and negative affect schedule; PSS = perceived stress scale; sAA = salivary alpha amylase; TBS = teacher burnout scale; TICS = trier inventory of chronic stress; TNF = tumor-necrosis-factor; TSES = teacher self-efficacy scale; TSI = teacher stress inventory. |